comscore Aarogya Setu app has major red flags when it comes to security concerns
News

Aarogya Setu app has major red flags when it comes to security concerns

The Aarogya Setu app has been created with good intents and purposes but the blatant security risks questions a lot of that.

Aarogya Setu

India like most other countries in the world is tackling the coronavirus crisis by imposing and recently extending lockdown. And in its efforts to convey information, the Modi government has come up with a new smartphone app called Aarogya Setu. This translates to bridging healthcare in Hindi. It’s present purpose is to provide information on the coronavirus crisis in India and tell its user if they have come in contact with someone carrying the virus. The app was launched back on April 2 and recently claimed that it has been downloaded over 50 million times within 13 days of launch. This means that the app broke the record held by Pokemon GO. Also Read - Aarogya Setu app reaches 50 million users in just 13 days; beats record set by Pokemon Go

But behind the positive intents and purposes of the app, it seems like it is riddled with security concerns. Delhi based privacy focused group the IFF or Internet Freedom Federation have raised red flags about the security concerns with the Aarogya Setu app. The app apparently fails to comply with the global privacy standards in its report. According to Sidharth Deb, policy and parliamentary counsel at Internet Freedom Foundation, the app is a potential surveillance tool in the hands of the government. Also Read - Government launches Coronavirus tracker app called ‘Aarogya Setu’: Here is how it works

“As such, the Aarogya Setu application appears to clearly be inconsistent with privacy-first efforts which are being considered by technologists and governments,” he writes. The IFF has compared the Aarogya Setu app to two other such Covid-19 tracking apps in term of safety parameters. These are the TraceTogether app from the Singapore government, and Massachusetts Institute of Technology’s Private Kit: Safe Paths project.

Too much information needed

The Aarogya Setu app asks its users to provide access to both Bluetooth and location services. The app goes on to warn users that if these permissions are denied, it could lead to a false assessment of a Covid-19 situation. A warning like this to an already perturbed person without the knowledge of the security issue would temp them to provide that permission. It also warns users to keep the devices on their person at all times. It also warns that an exchange of devices could mean a false report.

The whole purpose of the Bluetooth is to track if the smartphone of a Covid-19 positive person comes in range. Even in that case, it is not clear what kind of information will be shared between the two smartphones. According to IIT-Madras Professor V Kamakoti, it is estimated that “at least 50 percent of the population needs to register to make the app effective”. The problem with this is that there are hardly that number of smartphones held by the Indian population. Even if the app were to become effective, the elephant in the room still remains, which are the security concerns.

The IFF paper by Deb asks the question, “How will switching devices lead to a conclusion that someone is falsely identified as Covid-19 positive? Does this mean that people are categorized as Covid-19 positive based on the data collected by the application itself, instead of a formal test result to confirm a positive diagnosis? If this is indeed the case, there is a need to strongly commence dialogue to roll back the application and fine tune the entire process.”

Privacy agreement and source code

The privacy agreement of the Aarogya Setu app uses vague language. This brings up another issue which is that with such a flimsy privacy policy, the government could use the data from this app for other purposes. For example the app by the government of Singapore mentions that the data collected by it will only be used by the department of health. But the privacy policy of Aarogya Setu app has no mention of the ministry of health and family welfare anywhere according to IFF’s paper.

In terms of transparency of the app, the other two cases cited by the IFF paper have their source codes publicly available on GitHub. This enables ethical hackers to identify security concerns in the app and convey them to the developers. But the developers of the Aarogya Setu app have done none of this, which poses even bigger questions.

Data storage

Once a user launches the Aarogya Setu app they are prompted to provide their mobile phone number, verified with a one-time password. Following this the user is asked to enter their name, age, gender, profession, travel history, and known contact with a coronavirus patient. After providing all this information they are provided with a basic dashboard that provides base information and hygiene and social distancing protocols. There’s is also the feature to donate to the PM Cares fund which has been newly formed by the Modi government.

The data on the Aarogya Setu app is stored on the device as well as the central servers of the app. The terms and services of the app mentions that the data will be deleted after 30 days of recording it. But this only refers to the contact details of the user and not the anonymised or the aggregated data sets that the user may have been part of. This data could survive the present use for this app on its central servers.

“This clearly does not suggest intent on the part of the government to destroy these systems. As a result there is a risk the personal information of users may be held for the duration of this public health crisis and beyond,” Deb wrote.

The government agencies have been pushing this app since its launch. According to reports the HRD and Rail Ministries have apparently sent out advisories urging students, teachers and employees, and their family members, to download the app.

Various social media influencers have been reached out to as well in order to promote the app. One such social media influencer on Instagram shared a screenshot of a mail they received from a third party platform called VU Roll with BGR India. The mail clearly specifies that they will not be paid for promoting the app.

Image credit: Instagram @pavemented

The mail among other things reads, “There are no fees or charges in the promotion of Aarogya Setu app as it is a complete social awareness activity requested by the government.” Prime Minister Narendra Modi himself promoted the app despite the many security concerns while prolonging the lockdown till May 3. The internet Freedom Foundation has put out an explainer on the app as well educating people about the risks and how the app could be improved. The Aarogya Setu app has been developed by the Niti Aayog and is available in 11 major languages. And it’s not just the IFF, but there was an early analysis of the app by the Defensive Lab Agency which also raised red flags.

For the latest tech news across the world, latest PC and Mobile games, tips & tricks, top-notch gadget reviews of most exciting releases follow BGR India’s Facebook, Twitter, subscribe our YouTube Channel.
  • Published Date: April 16, 2020 7:17 PM IST
  • Updated Date: April 16, 2020 11:11 PM IST



new arrivals in india

Samsung Galaxy F02s
Samsung Galaxy F02s

8,999

Samsung Galaxy F12
Samsung Galaxy F12

10,999

POCO X3 Pro
POCO X3 Pro

18,999

Realme 8 Pro
Realme 8 Pro

17,999

Realme 8
Realme 8

14,999

Vivo X60 Pro Plus
Vivo X60 Pro Plus

69,990

Vivo X60 Pro
Vivo X60 Pro

49,990

Vivo X60
Vivo X60

37,990

OnePlus 9 Pro 5G
OnePlus 9 Pro 5G

64,999

OnePlus 9R 5G
OnePlus 9R 5G

39,999

OnePlus 9 5G
OnePlus 9 5G

49,999

Samsung Galaxy A72
Samsung Galaxy A72

34,999

Samsung Galaxy A52
Samsung Galaxy A52

26,499

Micromax In 1
Micromax In 1

10,499

Asus ROG Phone 5
Asus ROG Phone 5

49,999

Samsung Galaxy M12
Samsung Galaxy M12

10,999

Motorola Moto G30
Motorola Moto G30

10,999

Motorola Moto G10 Power
Motorola Moto G10 Power

9,999

Oppo F19 Pro Plus 5G
Oppo F19 Pro Plus 5G

25,990

Oppo F19 Pro
Oppo F19 Pro

21,490

Xiaomi Redmi Note 10 Pro Max
Xiaomi Redmi Note 10 Pro Max

18,999

Xiaomi Redmi Note 10 Pro
Xiaomi Redmi Note 10 Pro

15,999

Xiaomi Redmi Note 10
Xiaomi Redmi Note 10

11,999

Realme Narzo 30A
Realme Narzo 30A

8,999

Realme Narzo 30 Pro
Realme Narzo 30 Pro

16,999

Infinix Smart 5
Infinix Smart 5

7,199

Samsung Galaxy F62
Samsung Galaxy F62

23,999

Samsung Galaxy A12
Samsung Galaxy A12

12,999

Nokia 5.4
Nokia 5.4

13,999

Nokia 3.4
Nokia 3.4

11,999

Realme X7 Pro 5G
Realme X7 Pro 5G

29,999

Realme X7
Realme X7

19,999

Vivo Y31
Vivo Y31

16,490

Oppo Reno5 Pro 5G
Oppo Reno5 Pro 5G

35,990

Samsung Galaxy S21 Ultra 5G
Samsung Galaxy S21 Ultra 5G

1,05,999

Samsung Galaxy S21 Plus 5G
Samsung Galaxy S21 Plus 5G

81,999

Samsung Galaxy S21 5G
Samsung Galaxy S21 5G

69,999

Vivo Y12s
Vivo Y12s

9,990

Vivo Y51A
Vivo Y51A

17,990

Samsung Galaxy M02s
Samsung Galaxy M02s

8,999

Xiaomi Mi 10i
Xiaomi Mi 10i

21,999

Oppo A15s
Oppo A15s

11,490

Tecno Spark 6 Go
Tecno Spark 6 Go

8,499

Vivo V20 2021
Vivo V20 2021

24,990

Vivo Y20A
Vivo Y20A

11,490

Xiaomi Redmi 9 Power
Xiaomi Redmi 9 Power

11,999

Motorola Moto G9 Power
Motorola Moto G9 Power

11,999

Motorola Moto G 5G
Motorola Moto G 5G

20,999

Vivo V20 Pro
Vivo V20 Pro

29,990

Xiaomi Mi 10T
Xiaomi Mi 10T

35,999

Xiaomi Redmi 9i
Xiaomi Redmi 9i

8,299

Xiaomi Mi 10T Pro
Xiaomi Mi 10T Pro

39,999

Infinix Hot 10
Infinix Hot 10

9,999

Vivo V20 SE
Vivo V20 SE

20,990

Vivo V20
Vivo V20

24,990

Micromax In 1b
Micromax In 1b

6,999

Micromax In Note 1
Micromax In Note 1

10,999

OnePlus 8T
OnePlus 8T

42,999

Samsung Galaxy F41
Samsung Galaxy F41

15,499

Apple iPhone 12 Pro Max
Apple iPhone 12 Pro Max

1,29,900

Apple iPhone 12 Pro
Apple iPhone 12 Pro

1,19,900

Apple iPhone 12 Mini
Apple iPhone 12 Mini

69,900

Apple iPhone 12
Apple iPhone 12

79,900

Poco X3
Poco X3

16,999

Realme Narzo 20A
Realme Narzo 20A

8,499

Realme Narzo 20
Realme Narzo 20

10,499

Realme Narzo 20 Pro
Realme Narzo 20 Pro

13,999

Oppo F17
Oppo F17

16,990

Samsung Galaxy M51
Samsung Galaxy M51

22,999

Poco M2
Poco M2

10,999

Oppo F17 Pro
Oppo F17 Pro

22,990

Realme 7 Pro
Realme 7 Pro

19,999

Realme 7
Realme 7

14,999

Xiaomi Redmi 9A
Xiaomi Redmi 9A

6,799

Vivo Y20
Vivo Y20

12,990

Xiaomi Redmi 9
Xiaomi Redmi 9

8,999

Nokia 5.3
Nokia 5.3

13,999

Motorola Moto G9
Motorola Moto G9

11,499

Realme C15
Realme C15

9,999

Realme C12
Realme C12

8,999

Samsung Galaxy Note 20
Samsung Galaxy Note 20

77,999

Xiaomi Redmi 9 Prime
Xiaomi Redmi 9 Prime

9,999

Oppo Reno4 Pro
Oppo Reno4 Pro

34,990

Samsung Galaxy M01 Core
Samsung Galaxy M01 Core

5,499

Realme 6i
Realme 6i

12,999

Asus Rog Phone 3
Asus Rog Phone 3

46,999

OnePlus Nord
OnePlus Nord

24,999

Infinix Smart 4 Plus
Infinix Smart 4 Plus

7,999

Xiaomi Redmi Note 9
Xiaomi Redmi Note 9

10,999

Samsung Galaxy M01s
Samsung Galaxy M01s

9,999

Vivo X50 Pro 5G
Vivo X50 Pro 5G

49,990

Vivo X50 5G
Vivo X50 5G

34,990

Realme C11
Realme C11

7,499

Poco M2 Pro
Poco M2 Pro

13,999

Realme X3
Realme X3

24,999

Realme X3 SuperZoom
Realme X3 SuperZoom

27,999

Tecno Spark Power 2
Tecno Spark Power 2

9,999

Oppo A12
Oppo A12

9,990

Oppo A52
Oppo A52

16,990

Samsung Galaxy A21s
Samsung Galaxy A21s

15,999

Best Sellers