comscore Asus ordered by Delhi High Court to restrain from selling Zenfone-branded smartphones in India
News

Asus ordered by Delhi High Court to restrain from selling Zenfone-branded smartphones in India

Asus has been order to stop selling Zenfone-branded smartphones and other devices in the country. The order was delivered after Zen Mobile filed a trademark infringement case against the Taiwanese company.

  • Published: June 6, 2019 9:05 AM IST
Asus Zenfone 6 (19)

representative image


Asus has emerged as the most direct competitor to Xiaomi in the entry-level and mid-range price segment with its Zenfone series in India. The Taiwanese consumer electronics company has challenged with Xiaomi with devices like the Zenfone Max Pro M1, Zenfone Max Pro M2 and Zenfone Max M2. All these devices with their aggressive price and competitive specifications have sold well for the company. However, that run is now under threat due to a trademark infringement case. The Delhi High Court has issued an order that restrains Asus Technology Pvt Ltd from selling and advertising mobile phones, accessories and any other related products under the ZEN, ZENFONE or similar branding. Also Read - Asus ZenFone 8 Mini leaks again, this time revealing 2021 flagship-grade specifications

Also Read - Laptop guide: 5 best laptops under Rs 30,000 you can get for work from home

The court order was passed by a single judge bench of Justice Manmohan in a lawsuit files by Telecare Network India Pvt Ltd against Asus Technology Pvt Ltd. The lawsuit alleged that Asus infringed the trademark owned by the company. Telecare Network India Pvt Ltd claims that it is the registered proprietor of the trademarks ZEN and ZENMOBILE under the Trade Marks Act of 1999. According to Bar and Bench, the lawsuit adds that the company has extensively using these trademarks for selling its feature phones, smartphones, tablets and accessories under Zen brand since 2008. Also Read - Asus ROG Phone 5 pre-orders begin today in India at 12pm: Here's how you can pre-book

The plaintiff claimed that Asus had adopted an identical trademark in the form of ZENFONE for selling its own smartphones, which are allegedly identical to those sold by Telecare Network India Pvt Ltd under its own brand. The lawsuit also argues that since both the brands sell devices under the same price segment, the use of ZENFONE trademark by Asus could cause confusion in the minds of public and consumers could perceive that the two brands are associated. The plaintiff thus argues that Asus adopted “ZEN” brand in India with mala fide intent and take advantage of its “goodwill and reputation”.

Asus informed the court that the Zen branding was spearheaded by Jonney Shih, who the company claims is a believer of the ancient Zen philosophy and use of Zenfone branding is a reflection of his belief. The Taiwanese company also argues that use of ZEN branding was common to trade and should be deemed generic in nature. The company also cites a search report conducted on the Trade Marks Registry website showing that various third-party manufacturers had the mark ZEN registered.

Watch: Xiaomi Redmi Note 7 Pro First Look

According to media reports, Asus also argued that there is no scope for confusion or deception regarding the Zen branding. Senior Advocate Sandeep Sethi with Advocates Daksh Kumar and Sumit R Sharma, representing Asus, told the court that the Zenfone branding was coupled with its house mark Asus, which identifies the origin of the product. The advocates also contended that the plaintiff was disentitled from claiming exclusivity or monopoly over a part of the label or device under Section 17 (2) of the Act.

After hearing both the parties, the Court said that trademarks and trade names are meant to ensure that people do not get confused about the source of goods and services. It also contented Asus’ argument of the term “Zen” being generic in nature. The Court agreed that Zen word is generic but it cannot be a generic mark with regards to mobile phones. ” a word may be generic qua a specific business or trade or industry but not across the board for all business or trades or industries. Consequently, though ZEN is a generic word qua a school of Buddhism, yet it is not a generic mark with regard to mobile phones and tablets as the said word has no connection or correlation with mobile phones or tablets,” the Court said.

The Court thus observed that the plaintiff was entitled to protection for the trademark even without proof of it having acquired secondary signature. It dismissed the search report showed by Asus saying that mention of the mark in the report does not prove that it is being used by third parties. The Court also added that Asus itself had applied for the trademark ZENFONE and it cannot be “permitted to approbate and reprobate” and was stopped from arguing that the mark is generic or common to trade.

The Court, citing facts shown in the form of evidence, noted that the plaintiff had shown prior use of the mark since 2008 while Asus began selling devices under Zenfone brand only in 2014. The Justice Manmohan concluded that Asus’ adoption of the Zen mark was in bad faith. It further directed Asus to stop selling directly or indirectly, offer or advertise for “mobile phones and/or mobile accessories and/or any other related products or any other goods under the trademark ZEN, ZENFONE and/or any other trademark identical and/or deceptively similar to the trademark ZEN and ZEN Mobile, after eight weeks starting May 28.

“The ASUS legal team is currently working with the Delhi High Court in India to resolve the Zen Mobiles and ZenFone trademark lawsuit. The supply of ASUS smartphones, notebooks and other products, as well as technical support and after-sales service for all ASUS products remain unchanged for all consumers,” the company said in a statement. It needs to be seen whether the verdict by Delhi High Court affects Asus’ plan to launch the Zenfone 6 in the country. The next hearing for the case is scheduled for July 10.

For the latest tech news across the world, latest PC and Mobile games, tips & tricks, top-notch gadget reviews of most exciting releases follow BGR India’s Facebook, Twitter, subscribe our YouTube Channel.
  • Published Date: June 6, 2019 9:05 AM IST


You Might be Interested

Asus ZenFone 6

15999

Android OS, v4.3 (Jelly Bean), upgradable to v4.4.2 (KitKat)
Dual-core 2 GHz
13 MP, 4128 x 3096 pixels, autofocus, LED flash

new arrivals in india

Samsung Galaxy F02s
Samsung Galaxy F02s

8,999

Samsung Galaxy F12
Samsung Galaxy F12

10,999

POCO X3 Pro
POCO X3 Pro

18,999

Realme 8 Pro
Realme 8 Pro

17,999

Realme 8
Realme 8

14,999

Vivo X60 Pro Plus
Vivo X60 Pro Plus

69,990

Vivo X60 Pro
Vivo X60 Pro

49,990

Vivo X60
Vivo X60

37,990

OnePlus 9 Pro 5G
OnePlus 9 Pro 5G

64,999

OnePlus 9R 5G
OnePlus 9R 5G

39,999

OnePlus 9 5G
OnePlus 9 5G

49,999

Samsung Galaxy A72
Samsung Galaxy A72

34,999

Samsung Galaxy A52
Samsung Galaxy A52

26,499

Micromax In 1
Micromax In 1

10,499

Asus ROG Phone 5
Asus ROG Phone 5

49,999

Samsung Galaxy M12
Samsung Galaxy M12

10,999

Motorola Moto G30
Motorola Moto G30

10,999

Motorola Moto G10 Power
Motorola Moto G10 Power

9,999

Oppo F19 Pro Plus 5G
Oppo F19 Pro Plus 5G

25,990

Oppo F19 Pro
Oppo F19 Pro

21,490

Xiaomi Redmi Note 10 Pro Max
Xiaomi Redmi Note 10 Pro Max

18,999

Xiaomi Redmi Note 10 Pro
Xiaomi Redmi Note 10 Pro

15,999

Xiaomi Redmi Note 10
Xiaomi Redmi Note 10

11,999

Realme Narzo 30A
Realme Narzo 30A

8,999

Realme Narzo 30 Pro
Realme Narzo 30 Pro

16,999

Infinix Smart 5
Infinix Smart 5

7,199

Samsung Galaxy F62
Samsung Galaxy F62

23,999

Samsung Galaxy A12
Samsung Galaxy A12

12,999

Nokia 5.4
Nokia 5.4

13,999

Nokia 3.4
Nokia 3.4

11,999

Realme X7 Pro 5G
Realme X7 Pro 5G

29,999

Realme X7
Realme X7

19,999

Vivo Y31
Vivo Y31

16,490

Oppo Reno5 Pro 5G
Oppo Reno5 Pro 5G

35,990

Samsung Galaxy S21 Ultra 5G
Samsung Galaxy S21 Ultra 5G

1,05,999

Samsung Galaxy S21 Plus 5G
Samsung Galaxy S21 Plus 5G

81,999

Samsung Galaxy S21 5G
Samsung Galaxy S21 5G

69,999

Vivo Y12s
Vivo Y12s

9,990

Vivo Y51A
Vivo Y51A

17,990

Samsung Galaxy M02s
Samsung Galaxy M02s

8,999

Xiaomi Mi 10i
Xiaomi Mi 10i

21,999

Oppo A15s
Oppo A15s

11,490

Tecno Spark 6 Go
Tecno Spark 6 Go

8,499

Vivo V20 2021
Vivo V20 2021

24,990

Vivo Y20A
Vivo Y20A

11,490

Xiaomi Redmi 9 Power
Xiaomi Redmi 9 Power

11,999

Motorola Moto G9 Power
Motorola Moto G9 Power

11,999

Motorola Moto G 5G
Motorola Moto G 5G

20,999

Vivo V20 Pro
Vivo V20 Pro

29,990

Xiaomi Mi 10T
Xiaomi Mi 10T

35,999

Xiaomi Redmi 9i
Xiaomi Redmi 9i

8,299

Xiaomi Mi 10T Pro
Xiaomi Mi 10T Pro

39,999

Infinix Hot 10
Infinix Hot 10

9,999

Vivo V20 SE
Vivo V20 SE

20,990

Vivo V20
Vivo V20

24,990

Micromax In 1b
Micromax In 1b

6,999

Micromax In Note 1
Micromax In Note 1

10,999

OnePlus 8T
OnePlus 8T

42,999

Samsung Galaxy F41
Samsung Galaxy F41

15,499

Apple iPhone 12 Pro Max
Apple iPhone 12 Pro Max

1,29,900

Apple iPhone 12 Pro
Apple iPhone 12 Pro

1,19,900

Apple iPhone 12 Mini
Apple iPhone 12 Mini

69,900

Apple iPhone 12
Apple iPhone 12

79,900

Poco X3
Poco X3

16,999

Realme Narzo 20A
Realme Narzo 20A

8,499

Realme Narzo 20
Realme Narzo 20

10,499

Realme Narzo 20 Pro
Realme Narzo 20 Pro

13,999

Oppo F17
Oppo F17

16,990

Samsung Galaxy M51
Samsung Galaxy M51

22,999

Poco M2
Poco M2

10,999

Oppo F17 Pro
Oppo F17 Pro

22,990

Realme 7 Pro
Realme 7 Pro

19,999

Realme 7
Realme 7

14,999

Xiaomi Redmi 9A
Xiaomi Redmi 9A

6,799

Vivo Y20
Vivo Y20

12,990

Xiaomi Redmi 9
Xiaomi Redmi 9

8,999

Nokia 5.3
Nokia 5.3

13,999

Motorola Moto G9
Motorola Moto G9

11,499

Realme C15
Realme C15

9,999

Realme C12
Realme C12

8,999

Samsung Galaxy Note 20
Samsung Galaxy Note 20

77,999

Xiaomi Redmi 9 Prime
Xiaomi Redmi 9 Prime

9,999

Oppo Reno4 Pro
Oppo Reno4 Pro

34,990

Samsung Galaxy M01 Core
Samsung Galaxy M01 Core

5,499

Realme 6i
Realme 6i

12,999

Asus Rog Phone 3
Asus Rog Phone 3

46,999

OnePlus Nord
OnePlus Nord

24,999

Infinix Smart 4 Plus
Infinix Smart 4 Plus

7,999

Xiaomi Redmi Note 9
Xiaomi Redmi Note 9

10,999

Samsung Galaxy M01s
Samsung Galaxy M01s

9,999

Vivo X50 Pro 5G
Vivo X50 Pro 5G

49,990

Vivo X50 5G
Vivo X50 5G

34,990

Realme C11
Realme C11

7,499

Poco M2 Pro
Poco M2 Pro

13,999

Realme X3
Realme X3

24,999

Realme X3 SuperZoom
Realme X3 SuperZoom

27,999

Tecno Spark Power 2
Tecno Spark Power 2

9,999

Oppo A12
Oppo A12

9,990

Oppo A52
Oppo A52

16,990

Samsung Galaxy A21s
Samsung Galaxy A21s

15,999

Best Sellers