comscore Consent is not the key to privacy protection
News

Consent is not the key to privacy protection

Supreme Court of India recently passed a judgement making privacy citizens' fundamental right.

  • Published: September 21, 2017 4:05 PM IST
reight-to-privacy-fundamental-right

The Supreme Court has set the tone on the momentous question of the citizens’ fundamental right to privacy with its judgment on the K.S. Puttaswamy case. As we grasp the details and the contours of the right, we are also acutely aware of the speed with which society is being changed by digital technology. The rush to “cashless India , the spread of smartphones throughout society increasing the extent to which we are tracked, profiled, aggregated and predicted by the networks that used to just ring the telephone numbers we dialed are just two examples. Whatever “privacy” used to mean, it is clear to all of us, as it was to the justices in the Supreme Court that the problems collected under that rubric are changing very rapidly. Also Read - Samsung Galaxy S20 FE Long-term Review

Also Read - OnePlus India partners American Express for cashback deals, EMI offers and more

There is a forest of details to consider, in the aftermath of the Supreme Court’s ruling. But no matter what happens in future, we continue to move rapidly towards Digital India, towards the “India Stack” and all the other panoply of “amazing new services” that startups wish to roll out for, or over, us. Unless we have our basic concepts right, we will be faced with new facts on the ground, indeed with whole new social realities, before we are ready to understand their consequences or make wise social policy about them. The most important conceptual mistake we are currently being urged to make is the belief that privacy is only about consent . Also Read - India bans 43 more Chinese apps over security concerns

Twentieth-century surveillance was conducted only by governments, against criminals or political adversaries. They used tools such as wiretapping for listening to particular telephone conversations. Twenty-first century surveillance is conducted by businesses as well as governments. They now use “lifetapping” the ability to collect massive amounts of data on the locations, movements, wishes, thoughts, activities, and habits of entire populations.

Lifetapping leads to “data-mining , the recognition of large-scale patterns in human behavior that allow the prediction of individual human desires and actions. Businesses use these outputs to sell advertising. Governing regimes, like the Chinese Communist Party, explicitly intend to use those results to eliminate political disagreement, to extinguish the very ideas of democracy, and the rule of law through perfect political repression.

In this new technological context, the data flows that define the distribution of power in society are not bilateral, not about a series of individual transactions. They are all interrelated. Each block of information we give away about ourselves also changes what is known about our family members, our friends, our neighbors people we are “like” in all sorts of predictable and unexpected ways. Those likes, comments and emojis, all tell a story. ALSO READ: Apple iPhone X Face ID feature raises concerns around privacy and surveillance

When each of our individual actions affects the wellbeing of everyone else, we use “environmental law , not “transactional law” to regulate and govern in the interests of society. In environmental law, consent is *not* as in areas like contracts and commercial regulation, finance, or medical treatment the standard of compliance with the rules. In environmental law, we set overall social standards of care, and everyone must follow them.

You can’t consent to having your children breathe dirtier air, or drink dirtier water, than the environmental laws of developed society allow. We don’t allow contracting around environmental standards, because no individual can foresee, understand, or consent to all the consequences that follow, not only for him but for everyone else, from degrading the environment. None of us are safe, that is, unless all of us are.

Parties who want to make a profit, or slice off some of our political liberties, find it convenient to talk about “consent” as the heart of data democracy. They want us to believe that a “consent layer”, which is really nothing more than a checkbox on a form, somehow magically resolves all issues of privacy in digital India. They want us to believe that environmental standards protecting us against lifetapping by foreign corporates, or an over-powerful State, or local data entrepreneurs are unnecessary, even harmful. It will be better for us to let the local players handle our data because, “Digital Colonialism” is a dangerous path. But data-miners are like other miners when they come to you with a story about how everyone will be better off if you just sign here at the bottom of the form, their hurry to get your consent means that you’re being asked to do a deal way better for them than it is for you. We should not be making such a deal.

Privacy, which is thankfully no longer an elitist concept, will not be protected by a mechanism of individual “consent , but needs “environmental standards of cleanliness and safety that applies to everyone equally . Otherwise, we will simply be pushing the environmental disaster presently sweeping the West and bringing it to India with an Indian face. What we need today, as we needed it seventy years ago, is no rule of the Anglo-English consensus but the correct principles that apply to all parties alike. That will be true digital independence.

Eben Moglen is Professor of Law and Legal History at Columbia Law School in the city of New York and Founder President of the Software Freedom Law Center.

Mishi Choudhary is the Legal Director and President of SFLC.in.

For the latest tech news across the world, latest PC and Mobile games, tips & tricks, top-notch gadget reviews of most exciting releases follow BGR India’s Facebook, Twitter, subscribe our YouTube Channel.
  • Published Date: September 21, 2017 4:05 PM IST



new arrivals in india

Infinix Smart 5
Infinix Smart 5

7,199

Samsung Galaxy F62
Samsung Galaxy F62

23,999

Nokia 5.4
Nokia 5.4

13,999

Nokia 3.4
Nokia 3.4

11,999

Realme X7 Pro 5G
Realme X7 Pro 5G

29,999

Realme X7
Realme X7

19,999

Vivo Y31
Vivo Y31

16,490

Oppo Reno5 Pro 5G
Oppo Reno5 Pro 5G

35,990

Samsung Galaxy S21 Ultra 5G
Samsung Galaxy S21 Ultra 5G

1,05,999

Samsung Galaxy S21 Plus 5G
Samsung Galaxy S21 Plus 5G

81,999

Samsung Galaxy S21 5G
Samsung Galaxy S21 5G

69,999

Vivo Y12s
Vivo Y12s

9,990

Vivo Y51A
Vivo Y51A

17,990

Samsung Galaxy M02s
Samsung Galaxy M02s

8,999

Xiaomi Mi 10i
Xiaomi Mi 10i

21,999

Oppo A15s
Oppo A15s

11,490

Tecno Spark 6 Go
Tecno Spark 6 Go

8,499

Vivo V20 2021
Vivo V20 2021

24,990

Vivo Y20A
Vivo Y20A

11,490

Xiaomi Redmi 9 Power
Xiaomi Redmi 9 Power

11,999

Motorola Moto G9 Power
Motorola Moto G9 Power

11,999

Motorola Moto G 5G
Motorola Moto G 5G

20,999

Vivo V20 Pro
Vivo V20 Pro

29,990

Xiaomi Mi 10T
Xiaomi Mi 10T

35,999

Xiaomi Redmi 9i
Xiaomi Redmi 9i

8,299

Xiaomi Mi 10T Pro
Xiaomi Mi 10T Pro

39,999

Infinix Hot 10
Infinix Hot 10

9,999

Vivo V20 SE
Vivo V20 SE

20,990

Vivo V20
Vivo V20

24,990

Micromax In 1b
Micromax In 1b

6,999

Micromax In Note 1
Micromax In Note 1

10,999

OnePlus 8T
OnePlus 8T

42,999

Samsung Galaxy F41
Samsung Galaxy F41

15,499

Apple iPhone 12 Pro Max
Apple iPhone 12 Pro Max

1,29,900

Apple iPhone 12 Pro
Apple iPhone 12 Pro

1,19,900

Apple iPhone 12 Mini
Apple iPhone 12 Mini

69,900

Apple iPhone 12
Apple iPhone 12

79,900

Poco X3
Poco X3

16,999

Realme Narzo 20A
Realme Narzo 20A

8,499

Realme Narzo 20
Realme Narzo 20

10,499

Realme Narzo 20 Pro
Realme Narzo 20 Pro

13,999

Oppo F17
Oppo F17

16,990

Samsung Galaxy M51
Samsung Galaxy M51

22,999

Poco M2
Poco M2

10,999

Oppo F17 Pro
Oppo F17 Pro

22,990

Realme 7 Pro
Realme 7 Pro

19,999

Realme 7
Realme 7

14,999

Xiaomi Redmi 9A
Xiaomi Redmi 9A

6,799

Vivo Y20
Vivo Y20

12,990

Xiaomi Redmi 9
Xiaomi Redmi 9

8,999

Nokia 5.3
Nokia 5.3

13,999

Motorola Moto G9
Motorola Moto G9

11,499

Realme C15
Realme C15

9,999

Realme C12
Realme C12

8,999

Samsung Galaxy Note 20
Samsung Galaxy Note 20

77,999

Xiaomi Redmi 9 Prime
Xiaomi Redmi 9 Prime

9,999

Oppo Reno4 Pro
Oppo Reno4 Pro

34,990

Samsung Galaxy M01 Core
Samsung Galaxy M01 Core

5,499

Realme 6i
Realme 6i

12,999

Asus Rog Phone 3
Asus Rog Phone 3

46,999

OnePlus Nord
OnePlus Nord

24,999

Infinix Smart 4 Plus
Infinix Smart 4 Plus

7,999

Xiaomi Redmi Note 9
Xiaomi Redmi Note 9

11,999

Samsung Galaxy M01s
Samsung Galaxy M01s

9,999

Vivo X50 Pro 5G
Vivo X50 Pro 5G

49,990

Vivo X50 5G
Vivo X50 5G

34,990

Realme C11
Realme C11

7,499

Poco M2 Pro
Poco M2 Pro

13,999

Realme X3
Realme X3

24,999

Realme X3 SuperZoom
Realme X3 SuperZoom

27,999

Tecno Spark Power 2
Tecno Spark Power 2

9,999

Oppo A12
Oppo A12

9,990

Oppo A52
Oppo A52

16,990

Samsung Galaxy A21s
Samsung Galaxy A21s

15,999

Oppo Find X2
Oppo Find X2

64,990

Motorola One Fusion Plus
Motorola One Fusion Plus

17,499

Samsung Galaxy A31
Samsung Galaxy A31

20,999

Samsung Galaxy M01
Samsung Galaxy M01

8,999

Samsung Galaxy M11
Samsung Galaxy M11

10,999

Infinix Hot 9 Pro
Infinix Hot 9 Pro

9,999

LG Velvet
LG Velvet

Price Not Available

Xiaomi Mi Note 10 Lite
Xiaomi Mi Note 10 Lite

Price Not Available

Apple iPhone SE 2020
Apple iPhone SE 2020

42,500

Honor 30 Pro
Honor 30 Pro

Price Not Available

Best Sellers